5.1.18 *RADIATION VIEWFACTOR: symmetries and blocking

Product: ABAQUS/Standard  

Features tested

The *RADIATION SYMMETRY suboption of the *RADIATION VIEWFACTOR option is verified in this test suite by comparing results obtained from models using the different symmetry options to the results obtained from the full model without symmetries. A few different configurations are used to allow the testing of all the symmetry options in two-dimensional, three-dimensional, and axisymmetric cases. Some of the configurations are also used to test radiation blocking.

Since the primary interest of this verification suite is the calculation of viewfactors in nontrivial geometries, all the problems consist of only a single increment in a single step of steady-state heat transfer analysis. No analytical solutions exist for the nontrivial configurations selected; therefore, verification of the results is limited to a comparison of variations of this problem, run with different types and levels of symmetry. All the results documented can be reproduced by running the input files provided with the ABAQUS release.

I. Infinitely long square section tube

Two-dimensional models

Element tested

DC2D4   

Problem description

Four different two-dimensional models of the cross-section of the square tube are used: the full model, a half model with one reflection symmetry, a quarter model with two reflection symmetries, and a quarter model with cyclic symmetry. The full, half, and quarter models are shown in Figure 5.1.18–1. The two-dimensional models imply that the tube extends infinitely in the direction normal to the cross-section.

Figure 5.1.18–1 Two-dimensional square tube models.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv24sn000.inp1186.1.0503.5
xrv24snr10.inp1186.1.0503.5
xrv24snr20.inp1186.1.0503.5
xrv24snc04.inp1186.1.0503.5

 Element 21, Side 2
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv24sn000.inp–1502.1.0746.2
xrv24snr10.inp–1502.1.0746.2
xrv24snr20.inp–1502.1.0746.2
xrv24snc04.inp–1502.1.0746.2

Input files

xrv24sn000.inp

Full model, DC2D4 elements.

xrv24snr10.inp

Half model, DC2D4 elements, one reflection symmetry.

xrv24snr20.inp

Quarter model, DC2D4 elements, two reflection symmetries.

xrv24snc04.inp

Quarter model, DC2D4 elements, cyclic symmetry (NC=4).

Three-dimensional models

Element tested

DC3D8   

Problem description

Three different models of the square section tube are used. In all cases the complete cross-section is modeled, and the infinite extent of the tube is simulated by using periodic symmetry in the direction normal to the cross-section of the tube. The three models differ in the number of repetitions used for the periodic symmetry.

Figure 5.1.18–2 Three-dimensional square tube model.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 5
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38snp05.inp600.10.6578479.4
xrv38snp10.inp910.70.8696492.4
xrv38snp20.inp1148.0.9702503.3
2-D model1186.1.0000503.5

 Element 21, Side 4
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38snp05.inp–843.40.7491713.7
xrv38snp10.inp–1192.0.8898730.8
xrv38snp20.inp–1450.0.9706746.6
2-D model–1502.1.0000746.2

Input files

xrv38snp05.inp

Full cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=5).

xrv38snp10.inp

Full cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=10).

xrv38snp20.inp

Full cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=20).

II. Infinitely long square section tube with blocking

Two-dimensional models

Element tested

DC2D4   

Problem description

Four different two-dimensional models of the cross-section of the square tube and the blocking object are used: the full model, a half model with one reflection symmetry, a quarter model with two reflection symmetries, and a quarter model with cyclic symmetry. The full, half, and quarter models are shown in Figure 5.1.18–3. The two-dimensional models imply that the tube and the blocking object extend infinitely in the direction normal to the cross-section.

Figure 5.1.18–3 Two-dimensional square tubes with blocking.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv24sb000.inp1447.0.9970598.9
xrv24sbr10.inp1447.0.9970598.9
xrv24sbr20.inp1447.0.9970598.9
xrv24sbc04.inp1447.0.9970598.9

 Element 21, Side 2
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv24sb000.inp1451.0.9909527.3
xrv24sbr10.inp1451.0.9909527.3
xrv24sbr20.inp1451.0.9909527.3
xrv24sbc04.inp1451.0.9909527.3

 Element 106, Side 1
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv24sb000.inp–7388.1.0891.4
xrv24sbr10.inp–7388.1.0891.4
xrv24sbr20.inp–7388.1.0891.4
xrv24sbc04.inp–7388.1.0891.4

Input files

xrv24sb000.inp

Full model, DC2D4 elements.

xrv24sbr10.inp

Half model, DC2D4 elements, one reflection symmetry.

xrv24sbr20.inp

Quarter model, DC2D4 elements, two reflection symmetries.

xrv24sbc04.inp

Quarter model, DC2D4 elements, cyclic symmetry (NC=4).

Three-dimensional models

Element tested

DC3D8   

Problem description

Six different models of the square section tube and the blocking object are used. These models involve different combinations of the cross-sectional model and the number of periodic symmetry repetitions used to simulate the infinite extent of the tube and the blocking object. Three cross-section models are used: the full model, a quarter model with two reflection symmetries, and a quarter model with cyclic symmetry. Figure 5.1.18–4 shows the cross-section models used.

Figure 5.1.18–4 Three-dimensional square tubes with blocking.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 5
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sbp05.inp1461.0.7293514.0
xrv38sbrp5.inp1461.0.7293514.0
xrv38sbcp5.inp1461.0.7293514.0
xrv38sbcp10.inp1523.0.9013563.4
xrv38sbcp20.inp1452.0.9747597.7
xrv38sbcp50.inp1446.0.9931598.0
2-D model1447.0.9970598.9

 Element 21, Side 4
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sbp05.inp964.20.7880470.9
xrv38sbrp5.inp964.20.7880470.9
xrv38sbcp5.inp964.20.7880470.9
xrv38sbcp10.inp1263.0.9103503.6
xrv38sbcp20.inp1425.0.9697526.2
xrv38sbcp50.inp1441.0.9858526.9
2-D model1451.0.9909527.3

 Element 106, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sbp05.inp–6216.0.8492872.3
xrv38sbrp5.inp–6216.0.8492872.3
xrv38sbcp5.inp–6216.0.8492872.3
xrv38sbcp10.inp–7118.0.9575884.5
xrv38sbcp20.inp–7329.0.9857892.2
xrv38sbcp50.inp–7351.0.9908891.9
2-D model–7388.1.0000891.4

Input files

xrv38sbp05.inp

Full cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=5).

xrv38sbrp5.inp

Quarter cross-section model with two reflection symmetries, DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=5).

xrv38sbcp5.inp

Quarter cross-section model with cyclic symmetry (NC=4), DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=5).

xrv38sbcp10.inp

Quarter cross-section model with cyclic symmetry (NC=4), DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=10).

xrv38sbcp20.inp

Quarter cross-section model with cyclic symmetry (NC=4), DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=20).

xrv38sbcp50.inp

Quarter cross-section model with cyclic symmetry (NC=4), DC3D8 elements, periodic symmetry (NR=50).

III. Finite length square section tube

Three-dimensional models without blocking

Element tested

DC3D8   

Problem description

A unit-length tube with a square cross-section is analyzed. Four different models of the square section are used: the full model, a half model with one reflection symmetry, a quarter model with two reflection symmetries, and a quarter model with cyclic symmetry. Figure 5.1.18–5 shows the cross-section models used.

Figure 5.1.18–5 Three-dimensional finite square tubes with blocking.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 5
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sn000.inp52.450.0788451.7
xrv38snr10.inp52.450.0788451.7
xrv38snr20.inp52.450.0788451.7
xrv38snc04.inp52.450.0788451.7

 Element 21, Side 4
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sn000.inp–116.80.2948672.9
xrv38snr10.inp–116.80.2948672.9
xrv38snr20.inp–116.80.2948672.9
xrv38snc04.inp–116.80.2948672.9

Input files

xrv38sn000.inp

Full cross-section model, DC3D8 elements.

xrv38snr10.inp

Half cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, one reflection symmetry.

xrv38snr20.inp

Quarter cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, two reflection symmetries.

xrv38snc04.inp

Quarter cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, cyclic symmetry (NC=4).

Three-dimensional models with blocking

Elements tested

DC3D8   

Problem description

A unit-length square cross-section tube and a blocking object are analyzed. Three cross-section models are used: the full model, a quarter model with two reflection symmetries, and a quarter model with cyclic symmetry. Figure 5.1.18–6 shows the cross-section models used.

Figure 5.1.18–6 Three-dimensional finite square tubes with blocking.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 5
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sb000.inp227.70.1003367.2
xrv38sbr20.inp227.70.1003367.2
xrv38sbc04.inp227.70.1003367.2

 Element 21, Side 4
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sb000.inp97.980.3026378.5
xrv38sbr20.inp97.980.3026378.5
xrv38sbc04.inp97.980.3026378.5

 Element 106, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38sb000.inp–829.00.1331822.8
xrv38sbr20.inp–829.00.1331822.8
xrv38sbc04.inp–829.00.1331822.8

Input files

xrv38sb000.inp

Full cross-section model, DC3D8 elements.

xrv38sbr20.inp

Quarter cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, two reflection symmetries.

xrv38sbc04.inp

Quarter cross-section model, DC3D8 elements, cyclic symmetry (NC=4).

IV. Square section tubular ring

Axisymmetric models without blocking

Element tested

DCAX4   

Problem description

A tubular ring with a square cross-section is analyzed. Two different models of the square section are used: the full model and a half model with one reflection symmetry. Figure 5.1.18–7 shows the cross-section models used.

Figure 5.1.18–7 Axisymmetric models without blocking.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4sn000.inp–101.41.003587.4
xrva4snr10.inp–101.41.003587.4

 Element 21, Side 2
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4sn000.inp–2541.1.071761.6
xrva4snr10.inp–2541.1.071761.6

Input files

xrva4sn000.inp

Full cross-section model, DCAX4 elements.

xrva4snr10.inp

Half cross-section model, DCAX4 elements, one reflection symmetry.

Axisymmetric models with blocking

Elements tested

DCAX4   

Problem description

A square cross-section tubular ring with a blocking object inside it is analyzed. Two different models of the square section are used: the full model and a half model with one reflection symmetry. Figure 5.1.18–8 shows the cross-section models used.

Figure 5.1.18–8 Axisymmetric models with blocking.

Results and discussion

 Element 6, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4sb000.inp1624.1.005614.5
xrva4sbr10.inp1624.1.005614.5

 Element 21, Side 2
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4sb000.inp1300.1.063555.3
xrva4sbr10.inp1300.1.063555.3

 Element 106, Side 1
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4sb000.inp–7405.1.003894.3
xrva4sbr10.inp–7405.1.003894.3

Input files

xrva4sb000.inp

Full cross-section model, DCAX4 elements.

xrva4sbr10.inp

Half cross-section model, DCAX4 elements, one reflection symmetry.

V. Infinitely extending three-dimensional array of cubic objects

Two-dimensional models

Element tested

DC2D4   

Problem description

An infinite array of cubic objects is simulated. The two-dimensional models imply that the array extends to infinity in the third direction. Three different models are used: an array of nine by eleven objects, an array of nine objects with periodic symmetry in the direction perpendicular to the array, and a single object with periodic symmetry in two directions. The number of repetitions in the models using periodic symmetry makes these models equivalent to the nine by eleven array model. The models are shown in Figure 5.1.18–9 where the black square represents the model with two periodic symmetries and the gray squares represent the model with one periodic symmetry.

Figure 5.1.18–9 Two-dimensional cubic array.

Results and discussion

 Element 55, Side 1
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv24ab000.inp–11493.0.9635885.5
xrv24abp05.inp–11491.0.9635885.5
xrv24ab2p5.inp–11487.0.9635887.4

 Element 55, Side 2
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv24ab000.inp11490.0.9645597.6
xrv24abp05.inp11492.0.9645597.6
xrv24ab2p5.inp11499.0.9645603.7

Input files

xrv24ab000.inp

Nine by eleven array, DC2D4 elements.

xrv24abp05.inp

Nine object array with one periodic symmetry (NR=5), DC2D4 elements.

xrv24ab2p5.inp

Single object array with two periodic symmetries (NR1=4, NR2=5), DC2D4 elements.

Three-dimensional models

Element tested

DC3D8   

Problem description

An infinite array of cubic objects is simulated. The three-dimensional models consist of a single cubic element with periodic symmetry in three directions. Two models are used where the number of periodic symmetry repetitions is varied. The single element on which the models are based is shown in Figure 5.1.18–10.

Figure 5.1.18–10 Single element used for three-dimensional cubic array.

Results and discussion

 Element 55, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38abp05.inp–3425.1.011804.3
xrv38abp10.inp–3639.1.064804.4

 Element 55, Side 4
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38abp05.inp3212.0.9569712.0
xrv38abp10.inp3452.1.0154712.7

Input files

xrv38abp05.inp

Single object array with three periodic symmetries (NR1=4, NR2=4, NR3=5), DC3D8 elements.

xrv38abp10.inp

Single object array with three periodic symmetries (NR1=8, NR2=8, NR3=10), DC3D8 elements.

VI. Infinitely long finned tube inside another infinitely long tube

Axisymmetric models

Element tested

DCAX4   

Problem description

Radiation between an infinitely long, finned tube inside another infinitely long simple tube is simulated. The axisymmetric mesh used is shown in Figure 5.1.18–11. The infinite extent of the tubes is modeled with periodic symmetry in the direction of the length of the tubes. Three models with a varying number of repetitions for the periodic symmetry are used.

Figure 5.1.18–11 Axisymmetric mesh for finned tube models.

Results and discussion

 Element 82, Side 1
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4tb000.inp–4234.0.4805771.4
xrva4tbp05.inp–2522.1.064842.9
xrva4tbp10.inp–2521.1.064842.9

 Element 85, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4tb000.inp–1058.0.2182529.4
xrva4tbp05.inp–278.50.9952679.0
xrva4tbp10.inp–289.21.002678.7

 Element 92, Side 4
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrva4tb000.inp694.60.3753405.7
xrva4tbp05.inp2987.1.005427.7
xrva4tbp10.inp2988.1.012427.7

Input files

xrva4tb000.inp

Axisymmetric model without periodic symmetry, DCAX4 elements.

xrva4tbp05.inp

Axisymmetric model with periodic symmetry (NR=5), DCAX4 elements.

xrva4tbp10.inp

Axisymmetric model with periodic symmetry (NR=10), DCAX4 elements.

Three-dimensional models

Element tested

DC3D8   

Problem description

Radiation between an infinitely long finned tube inside another infinitely long simple tube is simulated. The two three-dimensional meshes used are shown in Figure 5.1.18–12: one is a full 360° mesh, and the other is a slice of this mesh that is used in conjunction with cyclic symmetry. The number of cycles used in the cyclic symmetry is varied. The infinite extent of the tubes is modeled with periodic symmetry in the direction of the length of the tubes.

Figure 5.1.18–12 Three-dimensional meshes for finned tube models.

Results and discussion

 Element 82, Side 3
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38tb000.inp–3285.0.5574768.5
axisymmetric model–4234.0.4805771.4
xrv38tbp05.inp–2315.1.137833.0
xrv38tbpc12.inp–2490.1.137844.5
xrv38tbpc24.inp–2605.1.027841.5
axisymmetric model–2522.1.064842.9

 Element 85, Side 5
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38tb000.inp–1118.0.2323537.7
axisymmetric model–1058.0.2182529.4
xrv38tbp05.inp–338.01.017678.2
xrv38tbpc12.inp–357.41.017682.4
xrv38tbpc24.inp–291.90.9987679.0
axisymmetric model–278.50.9952679.0

 Element 92, Side 6
RADFLVFTOTFTEMP
xrv38tb000.inp717.50.3772405.8
axisymmetric model694.60.3753405.7
xrv38tbp05.inp2957.0.9857426.5
xrv38tbpc12.inp3037.0.9862427.2
xrv38tbpc24.inp2992.1.025427.5
axisymmetric model2987.1.005427.7

Input files

xrv38tb000.inp

Full 360° model without periodic symmetry in the infinite direction, DC3D8 elements.

xrv38tbp05.inp

Full 360° model with periodic symmetry in the infinite direction (NR=5), DC3D8 elements.

xrv38tbpc12.inp

30° slice model with cyclic symmetry (NC=12) and periodic symmetry in the infinite direction (NR=5), DC3D8 elements.

xrv38tbpc24.inp

15° slice model with cyclic symmetry (NC=24) and periodic symmetry in the infinite direction (NR=5), DC3D8 elements.