Difference between revisions of "Format"

From CSE538 Online Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 90: Line 90:
 
Quizzes are intended to test students' understanding of material covered since the previous quiz (or the first lecture for the first quiz), and up to and including the lecture immediately preceding the date posted for the quiz on the [[syllabus|Syllabus & schedule]] page.  So, if a quiz is scheduled to take place on a given Wednesday during class, then the quiz will cover everything from the point where the previous quiz left off (or the first lecture for the first quiz), up to and including the material covered in the preceding Monday class.  Quizzes are open book, open notes, and open computer (though you are expected not to use the Internet to look for solutions), but given their short duration, there won't be much time available to search for answers in the books or your notes.
 
Quizzes are intended to test students' understanding of material covered since the previous quiz (or the first lecture for the first quiz), and up to and including the lecture immediately preceding the date posted for the quiz on the [[syllabus|Syllabus & schedule]] page.  So, if a quiz is scheduled to take place on a given Wednesday during class, then the quiz will cover everything from the point where the previous quiz left off (or the first lecture for the first quiz), up to and including the material covered in the preceding Monday class.  Quizzes are open book, open notes, and open computer (though you are expected not to use the Internet to look for solutions), but given their short duration, there won't be much time available to search for answers in the books or your notes.
  
−
There will be six (6) quizzes (see the course [[syllabus|syllabus]] for dates) and the quiz with the lowest score will be dropped when computing a student's final grade.  Note that all past quizzes are available on the course's [[exams|Past Exams & quizzes]] page, so that students can use them to become familiar with the format and practice completing a problem within the limited amount of time assigned to quizzes.  This offers another vehicle, besides the homeworks, to prepare for the quizzes.
+
There will be six (6) quizzes (see the course [[syllabus|syllabus]] for dates) and the quiz with the lowest score will be dropped when computing a student's final grade.  Note that past quizzes are available on the course's [[exams|Past Exams & quizzes]] page, so that students can use them to become familiar with the format and practice completing a problem within the limited amount of time assigned to quizzes.  This offers another vehicle, besides the homeworks, to prepare for the quizzes.
  
 
Quizzes will typically consist of one or two short problems that are to be completed in 30 minutes. Quizzes will take place during class time, typically during the last 30mins of the class, as shown on the [[Syllabus]] page.  As the lowest quiz score is dropped, it also allows students to miss one quiz.  As a result, barring a documented emergency or significant life-event, there will be no make-up quizzes in case a student misses a quiz.  Scheduled dates for all six quizzes (and homeworks) are posted on the course [[Syllabus]] page.
 
Quizzes will typically consist of one or two short problems that are to be completed in 30 minutes. Quizzes will take place during class time, typically during the last 30mins of the class, as shown on the [[Syllabus]] page.  As the lowest quiz score is dropped, it also allows students to miss one quiz.  As a result, barring a documented emergency or significant life-event, there will be no make-up quizzes in case a student misses a quiz.  Scheduled dates for all six quizzes (and homeworks) are posted on the course [[Syllabus]] page.

Revision as of 19:53, 11 June 2026

Course Organization at-a-Glance

Although the course Syllabus is organized at a traditional "lecture" granularity, the course consists of five (5) broad, logical units. Each unit is organized more or less the same way:

  • Preparatory preamble. This is material, mostly in the form of reading assignments (see Syllabus) and Preview problems that need to be completed before each module/lecture of the unit.
  • Information push. This is the equivalent of the "lecture" component in a traditional course and will mirror it relatively closely, though possibly with a different granularity. It is in the form of either synchronous lectures or asynchronous recordings that cover essentially the same material.
  • Assimilation. A review session, either synchronous or asynchronous, that goes over the material that was covered in the preceding "information push" for each unit and is intended to offer students the opportunity to go over the material one more time and make sure the underlying concepts are clear.
  • Assessment. This is meant to determine how well students have absorbed the material from a given unit. It will be in the form of a short quiz and/or a set of "homework" problems. Quizzes will take place in-class as shown in the Syllabus and will typically be 30mins long, while homework problems do not have time limits and are one of the mechanisms intended to allow students to practice for the quizzes. The collaboration policy for homeworks is as specified below in the Collaboration Policy and Academic Integrity Violations section, which students are urged to carefully review.

The five course units are as follows:

  • Unit 1: Probability Refresher & Basic Principles [~1.5 weeks – 3 lectures]
    • This unit is meant to reintroduce students to basic concepts and tools from probability that will be essential to the rest of the course. It also offers a first glimpse into how to apply those tools to obtain simple but useful characterization of system performance in a variety of settings. Basic performance metrics or interest are also introduced in this unit.
    • The unit is also used to introduce the students to the use of preview problems that they need to complete ahead of each session.
  • Unit 2: Discrete time Markov chains (DTMC) [~2 weeks – 4 lectures]
    • This unit introduces the concept of Markov chains and their use in modeling various basic systems to obtain performance metrics of interest. Students are also introduced to the concept of time reversibility that will be subsequently used to study more complex systems.
    • The goal of this unit is to help students understand what systems can be represented using discrete time Markov chains, and how to use them to extract performance metrics of interest.
  • Unit 3: Continuous time Markov chains (CTMC) [~2 weeks – 4 lectures]
    • This unit exposes the limitations of discrete time models and introduces continuous time processes and their use in developing a continuous time version of Markov chains, which are then applied to study a number of basic (single queue) systems. Applications leveraging those techniques to answer “provisioning” questions (how big or fast should my system be to meet certain performance levels) are also covered.
    • After completing this unit, students should understand both similarities and differences between discrete time and continuous time Markov chains, and be able to choose which one to rely on to model different types of systems. They will also be exposed to using results from CMTC analysis to evaluate and approximate some basic non-Markovian systems, and in the process become awareness of the limitations of the Markovian assumption.
  • Unit 4: Queueing Networks [~1.5 weeks – 3 lectures]
    • This unit builds on Unit 3 to consider more complex systems that can still be modeled using CTMC, namely, networks of queues. Those have applications in communication, computer, and manufacturing systems, and more generally systems that consist of sequences of connected “service” facilities. Students will gain awareness of the fact that what is gained in model sophistication is to a large extent lost in system intuition. In other words, while the models give answers, they don’t always give insight. The two are, however, useful in different contexts and this unit seeks to impart students with an appreciation for those differences.
    • This unit introduces students to models applicable to more complex interconnected systems, while also making them aware of their limitations and the assumptions on which they rely.
  • Unit 5: Advanced Modeling techniques and Applications [~4 weeks – 8 lectures]
    • This is the last and most demanding unit of the class. It exposes students to more advanced modeling techniques, both numerical and analytical, that overcome the limitations inherent to Markov chains. The unit also includes several applications of those techniques to a set of questions of relevance to the design of computer systems. It alternates between exposure to new tools and illustrations of how to apply them to problems of relevance.
    • After this unit students will either hate or love the class ;-), but hopefully will have acquired a set of powerful modeling tools and an understanding of how they can be used to not just evaluate system performance, but also design systems that aim to optimize different performance metrics.

Course Structure

Overview

Lectures are attempting to be more interactive than just following a "push" format. Specifically, a typical lecture will include:

  • reading assignment and preview problems that will need to be completed AHEAD of the lecture;
  • Occasional in-class problems that will be used to supplement the preview problems and/or offer a different perspective on the material covered in the preview problems;
  • lecture component that will be used to expand on or clarify concepts covered in the reading assignment and illustrated in the preview problems.

This format works ONLY if students have completed the reading assignment and preview problems ahead of the class where they will be covered. As a result, students are expected to turn-in (using Canvas) their preview problem at the beginning of each class. Occasionally, students may be (randomly) asked to provide a brief overview of their solution to the preview problems.

Grading

Grading has four components: (1) Preview problems, (2) Homeworks, (3) Quizzes, and (4) a Comprehensive Exam at the end of the semester. Preview questions are assigned for each lecture, homeworks are due every two weeks, and quizzes will similarly happen every two weeks (typically offset from the homeworks) - see the course syllabus for dates. The exam will take place during exam week at the end of the semester. Quizzes and the exam are assigned the bulk of the grading weight, while preview problems and homeworks are mostly intended as preparation for the quizzes and the exam.

Specifically, neither preview problems nor homeworks will be graded based on correctness of the solution. Instead, grading of both will be based on whether or not there has been a genuine attempt at solving them, i.e., solutions that demonstrate an honest effort will get a grade of 1, while solutions that don't will receive a grade of 0. As a result, since grading is not based on correctness, there will be only limited feedback on student submissions. Students are expected to check the solutions that will be posted in the Assignment section of the course's Canvas site and ask questions if they are unsure about them.

There will be six (6) 30 minutes quizzes (one for each unit, except the last unit that will have two) spread out over the semester. Quizzes will be held in class. The schedule for quizzes is as posted on the tentative schedule. Reminders for upcoming quizzes will be provided during the preceding class. As the goal is for every student to master the course's material, students will allowed one retake of each quiz. Retakes will be scheduled outside of class hours, typically on Fridays at noon. Students desiring to retake a quiz will need to notify the instructor within 24 hours of the quiz grade being posted. A student's grade for a quiz will be the higher of the original and retake grade, if any.

As mentioned, the exam will be scheduled during finals' week (December 10-16, 2025, as per the Registrar's Calendar). It will consist of 6 questions, one on the topic of each of the six quizzes. The grade received for each of those questions will replace the student's grade for the corresponding quiz if it is higher than the grade they received for that quiz.

The relative weights of these different components in determining a student's overall grade is as follows:

Preview problems 10%
Homeworks 10%
Quizzes+exam 80%

Quizzes and the exam are open-book and access to personal notes, homework solutions, and other related material is allowed. See below for additional details on allowed and prohibited resources, including AI agents, and how to best use them.

Reading Assignments

Reading assignments are intended to get you ready for the next class, so that you can participate during the discussions and ask questions aimed at clarifying what you may not have understood in the material. Reading assignments will typically be from the textbook itself, though additional material, e.g., from some of the online textbooks and notes in Online resources may also be used.

Preview Problems

They are assigned ahead of each lecture and meant to test your understanding of the material covered in the reading assignment for the lecture. Hence, successfully completing the preview problems will require reading the assigned material, as well as in most cases being proactive by asking questions on Piazza. Generic questions of the form "How do I solve Problem X" won't be entertained, but otherwise students will be provided with as much help as necessary to successfully complete preview problems. You will be expected to turn them in (using the Canvas Assignments page) before the start of the corresponding lecture. As an incentive to completing them, they count for a certain percentage (see Overview & Grading) of your final grade. Their grading will be "binary" (0 or 1) and based on whether you have meaningfully attempted to do them rather than correctness of your results.

In general, there are no specific limits on which resources students are allowed to use to complete preview problems. However, if students opt to rely on an AI agent to assist them, they should mention it explicitly and include a discussion of how the answer the AI agent provided helped them. In particular, solutions from AI agents will occasionally be wrong. Determining when and why this is the case can be useful, but blindly copying a solution provided by an AI agent will neither help you understand the material, nor will it position you well to absorb it during the subsequent lecture. In other words, like with any other system intended to assist you, using them passively is tantamount to shooting yourself in the foot... Similarly, you are free to discuss preview questions with other students and even collaborate on solutions. However, submitting a verbatim copy of another student's solution (or a solution from previous years), is both a bad idea (you are likely learning nothing) and will be considered a reportable Academic Integrity violation.

Solutions to preview problems will be accessible through Canvas. If you have problems accessing the page, first login to Canvas and then try again. The reason for making those solutions only accessible through Canvas, is that many/most of them come from the textbook and are not meant to be publicly distributed. As a result, please do not post any of them on public repositories and similarly do not forward them to students outside the class. If you do and are caught, this will be considered a violation of the the course's Academic Integrity policy and will earn you an immediate F for the class.

As a reminder, preview questions need to be typeset and NOT HANDWRITTEN. See the Formatting page for instructions on how to prepare the document you need to upload in the Canvas Assignment page for each homework.

Homeworks

Homeworks are assigned approximately every two weeks (there will be a total of 6 homeworks). They are intended as a first exposure to applying the course material to various types of problems, and in the process serve as preparation for the quizzes. Homeworks will consist of multiple problems, often from the textbook, which will target material covered since the previous homework was assigned. Like preview problems, homeworks are expected to be turned in on their due date before the start of class (see Late and Make-Up Policies for possible exceptions to this rule and the course syllabus for dates) and uploaded into Canvas.

Because homeworks are intended to help you prepare you for the quizzes, you are encouraged to ask as many questions as possible to ensure that they allow you to develop a comprehensive understanding of the course material. In particular, you can discuss homeworks with the instructor and TAs as well as, to a limited extent, other students provided that the final solution is your own. More broadly, you can discuss general concepts and directions with other students, but you need to be the one ultimately responsible for developing your solution. In particular, copying even just parts of another student's solution will be considered an Academic Integrity violation. Similarly, if you opt to rely on an AI agent to assist you in completing a homework, you should mention it explicitly and include a discussion of how the answer the AI agent provided helped you, especially since,as mentioned before, it will occasionally be wrong. Determining when and why this is the case can be useful, but blindly copying a solution provided by an AI agent will neither help you understand the material, nor will it position you well to absorb it during the subsequent quizzes and the exam. Even more than with preview questions, while the use of AI agents is not prohibited, it needs to be both acknowledged and handled with caution. In particular, because homeworks are intended to help students prepare for quizzes and the exam that they will take unassisted, blind reliance on the help provided by AI agents is likely to translate into very poor performance in quizzes.

Finally, like preview questions, homeworks need to be typeset and NOT HANDWRITTEN. See the Formatting page for instructions on how to prepare the document you need to upload in the Canvas Assignment page for each homework.

Quizzes

Quizzes are intended to test students' understanding of material covered since the previous quiz (or the first lecture for the first quiz), and up to and including the lecture immediately preceding the date posted for the quiz on the Syllabus & schedule page. So, if a quiz is scheduled to take place on a given Wednesday during class, then the quiz will cover everything from the point where the previous quiz left off (or the first lecture for the first quiz), up to and including the material covered in the preceding Monday class. Quizzes are open book, open notes, and open computer (though you are expected not to use the Internet to look for solutions), but given their short duration, there won't be much time available to search for answers in the books or your notes.

There will be six (6) quizzes (see the course syllabus for dates) and the quiz with the lowest score will be dropped when computing a student's final grade. Note that past quizzes are available on the course's Past Exams & quizzes page, so that students can use them to become familiar with the format and practice completing a problem within the limited amount of time assigned to quizzes. This offers another vehicle, besides the homeworks, to prepare for the quizzes.

Quizzes will typically consist of one or two short problems that are to be completed in 30 minutes. Quizzes will take place during class time, typically during the last 30mins of the class, as shown on the Syllabus page. As the lowest quiz score is dropped, it also allows students to miss one quiz. As a result, barring a documented emergency or significant life-event, there will be no make-up quizzes in case a student misses a quiz. Scheduled dates for all six quizzes (and homeworks) are posted on the course Syllabus page.

Quizzes, like preview problems and homeworks are open-book (the goal is to test your understanding and not your memory), but because they are only 30 minutes long, spending time searching for material in the book or your notes will typically not be a good idea. Nevertheless, towards helping with quickly locating relevant material, you will be allowed access to your computer during quizzes, BUT NOT INTERNET QUERIES. Issuing Internet queries for additional information during a quiz will be considered an Academic Integrity violation. Penalties for violations are as described below in the Collaboration Policy and Academic Integrity Violations section. There will be NO exception.


Practice Problems

A number of practice problems are available on the Practice Problems Canvas page together with their solution. If you have problems accessing the page, first login to Canvas and then try again. The reason for making those problems and their solutions only accessible through Canvas, is that many/most of them come from the textbook and are not meant to be publicly distributed. As a result, please do not post any of them on public repositories. If you do and are caught, this will be considered a violation of the the course's Academic Integrity policy and will earn you an immediate F for the class.


Late and Make-Up Policies

Preview problems: They are expected to be turned in before the start of class on their due date by uploading an electronic copy in Canvas. There are no make-up options for them, but each set of preview problems counts for only a very small fraction of the final grade (less than 0.5%).

Quizzes: Quizzes will be administered during classes (see the course Syllabus for dates and details). There will be no make-ups or adjustments for missed quizzes except for duly documented medical emergency or family emergency reasons at the instructor's discretion. Note though that since your lowest quiz score will be discarded, you are equivalently allowed to miss one quiz. This will be the default mechanism for handling a missing quiz.

Homeworks: As preview problems, they are expected to be turned in before the start of class on their due date. Extensions are typically not available for homeworks, as it will only make it harder for you to complete the next homework. However, because emergencies and/or special circumstances can arise, a single 48 hours extension will be granted to students who ask for it at least 48 hours before the homework's due date.
In addition, if you have already used your one-time 48 hours extension or failed to ask for it 48 hours in advance, you will also be allowed a one-time 48 hours extension but with a 50% grade penalty. In other words, if you ask for an extension at the last minute, you will be allowed this once, and if your point total on the homework is, say, 40/50, your actual grade for the homework will be 20/50.

Collaboration Policy and Academic Integrity Violations - Please Read Very Carefully

A copy of WashU's Academic Integrity Policy is available here and is in effect for this course. It applies to undergraduate students enrolled in all Schools and programs and master’s level students in the McKelvey School of Engineering, the Sam Fox School of Design and Visual Arts, and the School of Continuing and Professional Studies. Make sure you are familiar with it. The Academic Integrity webpage of the Office of the Provost offers additional information.

USE OF GenAI TOOLS IN THE CLASS: Modern GenAI tools have emerged as a powerful source of information, including in solving complex problems of the type that arise in Preview Problems and Homeworks. As the intent of both Preview Problems and Homeworks is to prepare and help students assimilate the course material, the use of GenAI tools is not prohibited as long as they assist with that task. However, the use of GenAI tools in helping solve Preview Problems and Homeworks MUST (i) Be acknowledged, and (ii) Leveraged to build understanding. This means that rather than simply pasting the solution provided by the GenAI system into what they turn in, students are expected to include a critical discussion of the steps of that solution in devising an answer. In particular, it is not uncommon for GenAI solutions to be only partially right, and deviate from the correct answer at some point. A critical analysis of the solution is, therefore, expected to identify such instances and explain where and why the GenAI solution went wrong. Failure to do so will not only elicit a grade of 0 for the question, but more importantly will likely jeopardize the student's chances of doing well on the subsequent quiz on the same topic.

ACADEMIC INTEGRITY VIOLATIONS, be they in the form of cheating during a quiz (e.g., copying another student's answer or seeking to find it on the Internet) or submitting material that is not your own, will result in the filing of a report with Academic Integrity in the Office of the Provost for formal investigation. The process that will follow the filing of such a report is detailed here.

  • Academic Integrity Guidelines for Preview Problems & Homeworks: See above for guidelines that pertain to the use of GenAI. In general, you should complete Preview Problems & Homeworks on your own, but you are not prohibited from discussing them with others. Turning in a verbatim copy of someone else work is, however, not acceptable and will be considered an academic integrity violation. If the violation is confirmed by the University's academic integrity committee, the minimum penalty will be an automatic grade (a deduction) of -5 points for a violation affecting a preview problem and -25 points for violations affecting homeworks (this assumes a maximum possible score of 50 points for the homework). A higher penalty may be levied, including an F for the class, depending on the severity of the violation. Those decisions are at the discretion of the instructor. Note also, that besides being counter to the principles laid out in the WashU's Academic Integrity Policy, submitting work that is not your own, be it for preview problems or homeworks, will only make it harder for you to assimilate the class' material and subsequently apply it, including in the context of quizzes.
In addition, many/most of the homework problems and their solutions come from the textbook and are NOT meant to be publicly distributed. As a result, please do not post any of them on public repositories and similarly do not forward them to students outside the class. If you do and are caught, this will also be considered a violation of the the course's Academic Integrity policy and will earn you an immediate F for the class.
  • Academic Integrity Guidelines for Quizzes: Collaboration is obviously not allowed, and any attempt to "share" problems or their answers with others will be considered an academic integrity violation and treated as such, as will be any attempt to solicit help from others, whether in-person or over the Internet. Broadly speaking, attempting to share an answer with/from another student of performing an Internet query during a quiz will be considered an Academic Integrity violation and will trigger an immediate referral to the university committee on academic integrity for subsequent adjudication. If the violation is confirmed, the resulting penalty will be at least an automatic grade of -10 for the quiz (10 is the maximum grade for a quiz). Additionally, depending on the severity of the violation, the instructor reserves the right to assign an overall class grade of F.
  • Practice Problems: You are entirely free to discuss any of those problems with other students. However, for practice problems available from the Practice Problems Canvas page together with their solution, it is explicitly forbidden for you to post them on any publicly available forum or to forward them to someone outside the course. Many of the problems and their solutions come from the textbook and are not meant to be publicly distributed. In case you violate this rule and are caught, you will be considered in violation of the course's Academic Integrity policy which will earn you an immediate F for the class. Note that this does not apply to practice problem associated with exams and quizzes from previous years, as those are already publicly accessible on the course wiki.