4.5.8 Test 13R: Simply supported thin square plate: random forced vibration

Product: ABAQUS/Standard  

Elements tested

S4    S4R    S8R5    STRI65   

Problem description

Material and geometry specifications are as given in Test 13: Simply supported thin square plate: frequency extraction, Section 4.5.5.

Loading:

Uniform pressure of 1.0 applied to all elements, with white noise power spectral density of 10000 Pa2/Hz in the frequency region between 0/Hz and 1000/Hz, using the fully correlated type of random loading.

Damping:

16 modes with direct damping. 2%.

Response location:

Peak PSD of displacement and stress at center of plate.

Reference solution

This is a test recommended by the National Agency for Finite Element Methods and Standards (U.K.): Test 13R from NAFEMS “Selected Benchmarks for Forced Vibration,” R0016, September 1993.

 Peak PSDPeak PSDFrequency
 (mm2/Hz)[(N/mm2)2/Hz](Hz)
Reference solution2063.201025.442.377

Results and discussion

The results are shown in the following table. The values enclosed in parentheses are percentage differences with respect to the reference solution.

Element typePeak PSDPeak PSDFrequency
(Mesh Size)(mm2/Hz)[(N/mm2)2/Hz](Hz)
S4 (4 × 4)1901.8 (–7.8%)844.25 (–17.67%)2.549 (7.24%)
S4 (8 × 8)2028.6 (–1.68%)981.39 (–4.30%)2.417 (1.68%)
S4R (4 × 4)2040.2 (–1.11%)665.98 (–35.05%)2.5043 (5.36%)
S4R (8 × 8)2062.2 (–0.05%)923.83 (–9.91%)2.4079 (1.30%)
S8R5 (4 × 4)2071.5 (–0.40%)1201.83 (17.2%)2.3759 (–0.05%)
S8R5 (8 × 8)2064.9 (0.08%)1011.33 (–1.38%)2.3767 (–0.01%)
STRI65 (2 × 4 × 4)1989.4 (–3.58%)942.13 (–8.14%)2.4028 (1.09%)

Input files

nfr13e4c.inp

S4 elements, coarse mesh.

nfr13e4f.inp

S4 elements, fine mesh.

nfr13f4c.inp

S4R elements, coarse mesh.

nfr13f4f.inp

S4R elements, fine mesh.

nfr1358c.inp

S8R5 elements, coarse mesh.

nfr1358f.inp

S8R5 elements, fine mesh.

nfr1356c.inp

STRI65 elements, coarse mesh.